Sewage sludge is a solid or semi-solid residue generated during wastewater treatment, rich in macro- and micronutrients, and potentially useful as an agricultural or forestry input. In addition to providing nutrients, it can improve soil physical characteristics, such as aeration and water retention capacity. However, its application should be done with caution, considering the possible presence of potentially toxic elements that can harm plant development. To deepen our understanding of the effects of sewage sludge application on seedling production, this thesis was structured in two phases. The first consisted of a systematic literature review followed by a meta-analysis, based on the PRISMA 2021 protocol, analyzing recent articles with quantitative data on the effects of sewage sludge on soils and plants. The second phase involved two pot experiments conducted for 120 days under greenhouse conditions, with different tree species used in urban landscaping, grown in substrates with varying proportions of domestic sewage sludge. The experiments were conducted to evaluate the effects of sewage sludge on soil chemical parameters, plant growth through non-destructive analyses (monthly stem height and diameter), and nutrient concentrations accumulated in plants through final chemical analyses of tissues separated between shoots and roots. In both experiments, statistical analyses included ANOVA and Tukey's test at a 5% significance level, as well as multivariate analyses (PCA and PFA) to identify the factors that most contributed to the variations between treatments. The first experiment was conducted in Sassari, Sardinia, Italy, using Nerium oleander as the species. The treatments consisted of T0 (100% commercial substrate), T1 (25% centrifuged sewage sludge (SS) + 50% urban soil (US) + 25% perlite), T2 (50% SS + 25% US + 25% perlite) and T3 (75% SS + 25% perlite), each with six replicates (pots). The control treatment (T0) showed the best initial performance in height, stem diameter and aerial biomass, followed by T1, T2 and T3. In the treatments with ≥50% sludge (T2 and T3), leaf chlorosis was observed in the seedlings during the first 60 days, possibly associated with the high initial electrical conductivity (T3 = 25.9 mS/cm) representing substrate salinity, which may have limited nutrient uptake. Despite this, from the third monthly assessment onwards, a gradual recovery in growth was observed in T2 and T3, possibly due to salt leaching and progressive nutrient release. Total and aboveground biomass were significantly higher in T0, while nutrient concentrations showed distinct patterns, with macronutrients exhibiting greater translocation to the shoots, while micronutrients accumulated primarily in the roots, with the exception of Mn, Zn, and B, which were more abundant in the aboveground tissues. Heavy metal levels in soil and plants remained below the limits established by European Directive 86/278/EEC and Italian Legislative Decree No. 99/1992. The second experiment was conducted in Botucatu (São Paulo, Brazil), with the native species Schinus terebinthifolius (Aroeira-pimenteira). The treatments consisted of T0 (commercial control substrate), T1 (4% dewatered and stabilized sewage sludge + 71% urban soil (red latosol) + 25% vermiculite), T2 (8% SS + 67% urban soil + 25% vermiculite) and T3 (12% SS + 63% urban soil + 25% vermiculite), all with six replicates. With monthly monitoring of pH and electrical conductivity (EC) of the leachate, a sharp decrease in salinity was observed over time, with T3 decreasing from 13.1 mS/cm to 5.08 mS/cm. The control treatment (T0) presented higher values of pH, organic matter, potassium, magnesium, sum of bases (SB), base saturation (V%), and boron. In contrast, nutrients such as available phosphorus, calcium, aluminum, sulfur, copper, iron, zinc, and manganese increased proportionally to the sludge dose applied. Regarding seedling development, T0 showed greater growth in the first 30 days, but the sludge treatments outperformed the control at the end of the experiment. There were no significant differences between the sludge treatments in total biomass and chlorophyll content, but all were superior to the control. In the chemical analysis of the plants, N, Ca, and Mn were more abundant in the shoots, while Mg, B, Cu, Fe, and Zn were concentrated in the roots. Phosphorus, potassium, and sulfur were evenly distributed between roots and shoots. Heavy metal levels in the soil remained below the limits established by CONAMA resolution 498/2020. Based on the two experiments, it is concluded that the application of sewage sludge, when monitored for salinity and composition, is viable and safe for use as a substrate in seedling production. Percentages between 12% and 25% proved to be more balanced, combining nutritional benefits without compromising initial plant growth. None of the treatments exceeded the legal limits for heavy metals or presented severe symptoms of toxicity at the end of the experiment. For future studies, we recommend the use of controls with local soil in addition to the commercial substrate, different irrigation depths, and more extensive monitoring of the elements present in the leachate throughout the cycle.
THE USE OF BY-PRODUCTS AS SOIL AMENDMENTS IN THE AGRICULTURAL/FORESTRY SECTOR / Lecciolle Paganini, Enzo Antonio. - (2026 Mar 19).
THE USE OF BY-PRODUCTS AS SOIL AMENDMENTS IN THE AGRICULTURAL/FORESTRY SECTOR
LECCIOLLE PAGANINI, Enzo Antonio
2026-03-19
Abstract
Sewage sludge is a solid or semi-solid residue generated during wastewater treatment, rich in macro- and micronutrients, and potentially useful as an agricultural or forestry input. In addition to providing nutrients, it can improve soil physical characteristics, such as aeration and water retention capacity. However, its application should be done with caution, considering the possible presence of potentially toxic elements that can harm plant development. To deepen our understanding of the effects of sewage sludge application on seedling production, this thesis was structured in two phases. The first consisted of a systematic literature review followed by a meta-analysis, based on the PRISMA 2021 protocol, analyzing recent articles with quantitative data on the effects of sewage sludge on soils and plants. The second phase involved two pot experiments conducted for 120 days under greenhouse conditions, with different tree species used in urban landscaping, grown in substrates with varying proportions of domestic sewage sludge. The experiments were conducted to evaluate the effects of sewage sludge on soil chemical parameters, plant growth through non-destructive analyses (monthly stem height and diameter), and nutrient concentrations accumulated in plants through final chemical analyses of tissues separated between shoots and roots. In both experiments, statistical analyses included ANOVA and Tukey's test at a 5% significance level, as well as multivariate analyses (PCA and PFA) to identify the factors that most contributed to the variations between treatments. The first experiment was conducted in Sassari, Sardinia, Italy, using Nerium oleander as the species. The treatments consisted of T0 (100% commercial substrate), T1 (25% centrifuged sewage sludge (SS) + 50% urban soil (US) + 25% perlite), T2 (50% SS + 25% US + 25% perlite) and T3 (75% SS + 25% perlite), each with six replicates (pots). The control treatment (T0) showed the best initial performance in height, stem diameter and aerial biomass, followed by T1, T2 and T3. In the treatments with ≥50% sludge (T2 and T3), leaf chlorosis was observed in the seedlings during the first 60 days, possibly associated with the high initial electrical conductivity (T3 = 25.9 mS/cm) representing substrate salinity, which may have limited nutrient uptake. Despite this, from the third monthly assessment onwards, a gradual recovery in growth was observed in T2 and T3, possibly due to salt leaching and progressive nutrient release. Total and aboveground biomass were significantly higher in T0, while nutrient concentrations showed distinct patterns, with macronutrients exhibiting greater translocation to the shoots, while micronutrients accumulated primarily in the roots, with the exception of Mn, Zn, and B, which were more abundant in the aboveground tissues. Heavy metal levels in soil and plants remained below the limits established by European Directive 86/278/EEC and Italian Legislative Decree No. 99/1992. The second experiment was conducted in Botucatu (São Paulo, Brazil), with the native species Schinus terebinthifolius (Aroeira-pimenteira). The treatments consisted of T0 (commercial control substrate), T1 (4% dewatered and stabilized sewage sludge + 71% urban soil (red latosol) + 25% vermiculite), T2 (8% SS + 67% urban soil + 25% vermiculite) and T3 (12% SS + 63% urban soil + 25% vermiculite), all with six replicates. With monthly monitoring of pH and electrical conductivity (EC) of the leachate, a sharp decrease in salinity was observed over time, with T3 decreasing from 13.1 mS/cm to 5.08 mS/cm. The control treatment (T0) presented higher values of pH, organic matter, potassium, magnesium, sum of bases (SB), base saturation (V%), and boron. In contrast, nutrients such as available phosphorus, calcium, aluminum, sulfur, copper, iron, zinc, and manganese increased proportionally to the sludge dose applied. Regarding seedling development, T0 showed greater growth in the first 30 days, but the sludge treatments outperformed the control at the end of the experiment. There were no significant differences between the sludge treatments in total biomass and chlorophyll content, but all were superior to the control. In the chemical analysis of the plants, N, Ca, and Mn were more abundant in the shoots, while Mg, B, Cu, Fe, and Zn were concentrated in the roots. Phosphorus, potassium, and sulfur were evenly distributed between roots and shoots. Heavy metal levels in the soil remained below the limits established by CONAMA resolution 498/2020. Based on the two experiments, it is concluded that the application of sewage sludge, when monitored for salinity and composition, is viable and safe for use as a substrate in seedling production. Percentages between 12% and 25% proved to be more balanced, combining nutritional benefits without compromising initial plant growth. None of the treatments exceeded the legal limits for heavy metals or presented severe symptoms of toxicity at the end of the experiment. For future studies, we recommend the use of controls with local soil in addition to the commercial substrate, different irrigation depths, and more extensive monitoring of the elements present in the leachate throughout the cycle.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


